And then... Finally!!
Two days in a row. Perfect, beautiful, creamy NOT FIZZY kefir.
So what did I change? I used the very minimum amount of milk. Put it in the cabinet at night; and in the morning, I give it a swish and put it in the water heater closet. I take it out in the evening and look. LOOK!
It's gorgeous. And it's pretty firm:
But a little swish loosens it up. It's thick, but not separated.
And it strained very, very easily.
Whew! Two days in a row. Hopefully this keeps up. I'd imagine that as the grains grow and mature and as the weather warms up, I won't have to move it to the closet. But until then, this is perfect.
I have totally replaced Andre's store-bought probiotics with this, and we'll see how he does. It's cheap and easy if it continues to be successful.
I'm sold.